This post may contain affiliate links. If you click through my referral link, at no additional cost to you, I may earn a small commission if you make a purchase. Thank you for supporting South Street & Co. Read our full disclosure here.
Reading Time: 3 minutes

Not only do we love social media but, the secret’s out, we love desserts too. And with these four locations, you can get pics for the ‘gram and make your tastebuds happy all at the same time!

To celebrate this Insta-worthy day, we’ve compiled four of Orlando’s tastiest dessert destinations that have treats that celebrate National Peanut Butter Lovers day officially on March 1st.

I wish I could congratulate the first person who thought of combining peanut butter with chocolate because they truly changed the dessert game. Although I know there are people out there that are morally opposed to mixing peanut butter with their sweets, I, on the other hand, prefer them together. It’s where savory meets sweet and, for me, it doesn’t get much better than that.

March 1st is the National Peanut Butter Lover’s day, and although I do love peanut butter just the way it is, I thought it would be sweeter to research peanut butter dessert creations you can find here in Orlando to celebrate this tasty holiday! Not only that, but while you and your sig-other or BFF are touring Orlando’s tastebud scene, you can snap some pics, do an Insta story and live your #BestLife. And let’s be real, sometimes you just need an excuse to order that dessert, so feel free to consider this your excuse!

Chocolate Peanut Butter Brownie Ice Cream

Source: https://kellyshomemadeicecream.com/sample-menu/

All of the best things combined into one treat? Yes please. As one of Kelly’s Homemade Ice Cream’s signature flavors, it’s a twist on a classic that cannot go untried. With three locations and hundreds of other flavors, it’s a dessert destination worth checking out for this fun holiday, and every other day after!

Peanut Butter Cup Donut 

Source: https://theglassknife.com/2017/10/our-artisanal-doughnuts/

Now we’re getting real creative with the sweets! Breakfast for dessert or dessert for breakfast, whatever you may consider this treat, I can say firsthand that it is divine! A warm donut with chunks of peanut butter chocolate treats and a warm fudge drizzle, this treat puts all the rest to shame. Made and served in-house at the Glass Knife in Winter Park, it’s worth scheduling a donut and coffee date to try this one. Trust me, when you take your first bite you won’t forget about it!

Peanut Butter Perversion 

Source: https://localpov.com/best-of/orlando/better-sex-local-secrets-orlando/

This dessert’s witty name fits in right at home as it’s served exclusively at Better Than Sex Dessert Restuarant in Orlando. From the sound, look, and imagined taste of this divine sweet, it seems like a game-changer. A decadent peanut butter silk pie covered with adult jelly, salted peanut butter bark, and a chocolate chip cookie dough crust, this dessert doesn’t leave any detail unnoticed.

Peanut Butter Crisp Cookie 

Source: http://www.gideonsbakehouse.com/menu

The newest addition at Gideon’s Bakehouse in Orlando, this cookie fits the occasion perfectly. This smooth Peanut Butter Cookie is filled with PB chips and house-made candied peanuts with caramelized vanilla butter crisps sprinkled throughout for added crunch! Two Words: Mouth Watering. Two additional words: Insta-Ready.

I’m already in peanut butter paradise reading about these treats! I hope to have inspired you to check out these local restaurants and see their creative twists on the peanut butter chocolate classic while also indulging in your visual sweet tooth– you won’t regret it!